I had several disastrously bad high school dance dates. Comically bad. My parents were the sort that encouraged us to always accept dates unless we felt we would be unsafe. So, if that meant going with the boy who shouted from across the room in the middle of class one day “HEY EMILY, WANT TO GO TO THE PROM?” a few days after your little brother asks incredulously “who would ask YOU to the prom?” and your father has sternly promised him that if no one asks his sister to the prom it will be HIM that takes you, and you think you might die from the embarrassment of it all….that meant politely (albeit with red, embarrassed cheeks and the whole class’ heads turning as though this painfully awkward conversation were a riveting tennis volley) accepting.

I won’t go into detail (most of these boys were nice people, the dates were just terribly awkward), but if we’re ever on a long car trip together, I could regail you with tales that would make you laugh till your stomach muscles cramped up, groan with discomfort, and roll your eyes from incredulity.
All that awkwardness aside, sometimes, the free (to me) dinner was the highlight of the evening. One such night involved what I’ve just mentally referred to as “pink pasta” ever since.
It’s nothing new, or particularly fancy, but when you’re in high school in a brightly colored, fluffy, sparkly dress, almost anything can be fancy, am I right? In essence, pink pasta is pasta with both alfredo and marinara sauce on it. It’s delicious. Like, really, really delicious.
I’ve been trying to expose Sophie to some new flavors lately, so we’ve been working on adding new flavors to foods she already likes. I figured fresh basil and spicier red sauce with peppers, onions, and mushrooms couldn’t go astray when paired with pasta, alfredo sauce, and a bit of cheese. I was right. Sophie LOVED it. We ate it one night, ate leftovers, and froze the rest for lunches or dinners another time. You could just as easily divide the recipe in half or divide it between two containers (one to eat, one to freeze) if you please.
Just know that even on your most awkward days… pink pasta can be just fancy enough to help you get through. I’m glad we had this talk.
Notes on the recipe: I made my own alfredo sauce using this recipe for Guiltless Alfredo Sauce from Our Best Bites with good success (the only changes I made were to decrease the garlic to 1 clove and combined everything in the pan instead of blending it first). We also really like using Newman’s Own Sockarooni sauce for the red sauce. It’s got peppers and onions and is very flavorful.
- 1lb short pasta, such as penne, farfalle, or rigatoni
- 2c your favorite marinara sauce
- 2c your favorite alfredo sauce
- ½c fresh basil, plus additional for garnish, if desired
- 1-1½c mozzarella cheese
- ½c fresh parmesan cheese
- Cook pasta in salted water 1-2 minutes less than the package directs (it will finish cooking in the sauce and in the oven). Drain.
- Meanwhile, make “pink” sauce by stirring together marinara and alfredo sauces in a medium saucepan over low heat until well blended. Stir in fresh basil.
- When pasta has finished cooking, toss pasta with pink sauce. Pour into a 9×13 baking dish. Sprinkle with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses.
- Bake at 350 degrees for 20-30 minutes, or until cheese is bubbly. Garnish with additional fresh basil if desired.

{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }
I was just looking at the expiration date on my sockarooni sauce yesterday,,,thanks for the great dinner suggestion!
You are a good sport Emily. And a kind one. And that is what I was hoping for when I encouraged you to accept every date invitation unless you truly felt unsafe.
And now you have a long car trip’s worth of good stories. WIn. Win!
p.s.
I LOVE pink pasta, harking back to the days with Olive Garden introduced me to the concept with their Ravioli. YUM!
I would LOVE to spend a long car trip playing bad date storie tennis with you. That sounds almost as good as this pasta.
p.s. this is how I make my lasagna – alfredo and marinara. Divine.
I love the combo of red sauce and alfredo together – but never thought to bake it in a casserole together. Great idea:)
YUM!!!
So Em, I’m one of those sad souls whose brothers took her to two of her school dances–not because she said no to other offers, but because she had no offers at all. Both dates (one with your dad, one of the most popular guys at Orem High, and the other with your Uncle Shawn, another of the most eligible Orem High bachelors) were more fun than just about any other date I ever had. (But don’t tell Bob)
Oh, believe me… it wasn’t that I was turning down any offers. I even had to go stag my junior year (I was on homecoming court without a date). My dad has told me all about how much fun he had with you as a date! My brother was 11 at the time, which somehow seemed less magical.
Man. My best ever: the football player who said [graciously] as he dropped me off afterwards, “I usually only do cheerleaders; but you were pretty fun.”
you’re sweet to still go on them despite how awkward they might’ve been – i would’ve looked the other way, which is so terrible of me. i love the alfredo and red sauce that you used in this pasta!!
This is such a great idea, I love simple pastas for weeknight meals!
I’m proud that your parents told you to accept all dates unless you felt you would be unsafe, my parents said no for me to ALL of them!
Sophie is even cute with pasta sauce all over her chubby cheeks!
Thank you for all your wonderful recipes. I appreciate the fact that at the end of the week I can look over your recipes and have some wonderful options for my family that are full of flavor.
This is probably one of the most amazing pasta dishes I have ever made and consumed in general! I added 1/3 pound of ground beef and 1/3 pound of ground spicy italian pork sausage to mine because my bf won’t eat anything without some meat in it but I’m sure with or without my addition it is seriously AMAZING!!!