banana cream pie

I am a little weird. I totally spaced that Tuesday is St. Patrick’s Day, but I had absolutely no trouble remembering that Saturday was Pi day (3.14). This tells me something important about myself: I probably think too much about food.

And I’m almost certain I don’t care.

This year, we had it narrowed down to two pies we were interested in: Three Plum (which we’ve never seen a recipe for but heard about on Pushing Daisies), and banana cream. Because we haven’t really figured out the logistics of three plum (and we think the texture could be really off), we decided to be safe and go with banana cream.

My usual banana cream pie is actually made with pudding and bananas and a little hint of cinnamon. When we ran the idea of banana cream past our good friend Adam, who was coming to dinner, there was a small pause over the phone. “… this is perfect. I ask for banana cream pie for my birthday every year.”

And then I knew that I couldn’t go for the cheater kind. I absolutely had to make a REAL-DEAL-NO-NONSENSE-FULL-FAT-HOMEMADE-FROM-SCRATCH banana cream pie.

I will be honest. I first thought of Paula Deen. After checking Food Network’s site for her banana cream pie options, I vetoed the chocolate banana cream and “banoffee” options, and felt very disappointed in her. I’m sorry, Paula. It’s nothing personal. Promise.

But salvation came in the form of Emeril Lagasse. Almost.

Emeril is rather famous for his banana cream pie with chocolate and caramel drizzle. Since he made his own custard, I decided to go with his recipe. But I had to tweak it, because it just wouldn’t have worked otherwise. So this recipe is inspired by Emeril, but it’s adapted for my taste.

I highly recommend that if you’re going to make this pie that you make it a day ahead. The banana flavor will intensify and you’ll think you’ve died and gone to calorie-dense banana cream heaven. Trust me.

Banana Cream Pie
Printable Recipe

Ingredients:
2c whipping cream (separated)
3 1/2c whole milk
3 egg yolks
2 eggs
1/2c cornstarch
1 1/2c sugar
1tsp vanilla
1/8tsp coconut extract (optional, but I recommend it)
pinch of salt
3lb bananas, sliced
1(9″) graham cracker pie crust (recipe below)

Directions:
Bring the milk, and 1/2c of the sugar to a boil in a medium saucepan, stirring to dissolve sugar. Remove from the heat. Meanwhile, whisk together egg yolks, eggs, remaining sugar and cornstarch till lighter in color in a medium bowl. Whisk 1c of the hot milk mixture into the eggs to temper them (so they don’t curdle. ew). Whisk in remaining milk mixture and return to the saucepan.

Bring to a simmer, stirring constantly (I use a whisk). Simmer about 5 minutes or until custard has thickened. Remove from heat. Strain through a strainer into a bowl if you want a finer texture. Stir in vanilla, coconut extract, and salt. Cover with plastic wrap, pressing down against the surface to prevent a skin from forming. Refrigerate about 4 hours. Custard will become very thick.

Whip 1c cream with 2 tsp sugar in a large bowl until stiff. Using a mixer or a spoon and a lot of upper body strength, stir whipped cream into custard until relatively smooth. It won’t be perfect.

To assemble, spread 1/2c custard mixture over pie crust. Form a single layer of banana slices. Top with about 3/4c custard and another layer of bananas. Top with yet another 3/4c custard and another layer of bananas. Spread all remaining custard (should be at least 1c) over bananas entirely to prevent any discoloration. Cover with plastic wrap pressed against the surface at least 4 hours or overnight.

To serve, whip remaining cup of whipped cream with a dash of vanilla and 2 tsp sugar until stiff. Slice pie into 10 slices (or more) and top with whipped cream or pipe whipped cream over surface.

Graham Cracker crust:
1 sleeve graham crackers, finely crushed (should give you about 1 1/4c crumbs)
4 Tbsp butter, melted
1/4c sugar

Combine crumbs, butter, and sugar. Press into a 9″ pie pan. I find this easiest using a cup to pack it down evenly.

Bake at 350 for about 20 minutes or until golden. Cool 10-20 minutes before filling.

8 Comments

  1. Thank you, thank you, thank you. I, like you usually make my banana cream pie with pudding mix. I was looking for a recipe to make for Thanksgiving that I could do a day ahead of time. I’m so glad I came across your site. The recipe looks perfect. Can’t wait to try it.

  2. Oh. My. Heaven. That cream/pudding mixture is heaven – the coconut extract is totally worth it. Can’t wait to actually eat the pie tomorrow!

    1. So, I made this pie and took it to my Stake’s Pioneer Day Breakfast…it got entered in the pie contest and I won Best Overall Pie ­čÖé Thanks for the awesome recipe!

  3. I just made this pie today and I’ve only licked my fingers of the filling and it was AMAZING!!! I’m so excited to eat it in 4 hours!

  4. I doubled the recipe and made two HUGE pies and used three sleeves of the graham crackers to make two crusts (still not enough lol). But everyone who ate the pie like a disproportionate amount of pie crust to filling ratio. I think next time I might just made some extra crust on a baking sheet, cut it up and add it like a spoon when serving the pie.

    I also used an ice bath and occasional stirring to cool down the custard for the first chilling and only put it in the fridge for about an hour. I wonder if this was the reason the pie custard was a bit runny.

    I substituted the coconut extract with coconut cream. Maybe added 2-3 tablespoons (for the double pie filling amount) of it until I was satisfied with the flavor. It definitely adds a something extra to the flavor. The pie was VERY GOOOD. The custard after sitting overnight tasted AMAZING. But I think it was a bit too sweet. I’ll cut the sugar down to half the amount next time I make it. And with the extra pie “crust”, I bet it will be even more amazing!

    I’m definitely saving this recipe for the future! Thank you for sharing ­čÖé

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.